| Year | League Champions | League MVP | Coach of the Year |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1995 | Spanky's Pink Team | RB Emmitt Smith, SPT | David Glab, CP |
| 1996 | Satan's Prisoners | RB Emmitt Smith, LL (83) | Marc Kitowski, M (78.63) |
| 1997 | Al's Dream Team | RB Barry Sanders, CP (77) | Marc Harris, SPT (81.76) |
| 1998 | Satan's Prisoners | RB Terrell Davis, BB (108) | David Glab, CP (88.73) |
| 1999 | Bone's Bitches | RB Edgerrin James, ADT (97) | Marc Harris, SPT (84.19) |